top of page

🤩 Among The Stars: March Update

It's that time again. For the moment, anyway, our curated starred review spreadsheet is up to date, y'all.


As a reminder, Martha Hickson curate and collate the starred reviews from six trade journals: 



I realize, of course, that other sites/blogs award stars, too... but these are the journals we've chosen to focus on.


An Extra Nerdy Update!

As both a book nerd AND a nerd more generally, I'm fascinated by the data this spreadsheet produces. I love scanning all the rows and columns to get a sense of how starred reviews are distributed amongst the data points we curate. Each month. I do a little math to share the shake down of stars across all the journals we keep track of. However, since the beginning of this project, I've wanted to create a sheet that did the moth for me... and this month I finally did it!


While I'll continue to post monthly updates here, you can also keep track of this nerdy data by checking out the tab labeled "statistics" at the bottom of the spreadsheet.

An animated GIF showing navigation tabs labeled "2025," "Schedule 2025," "2024," "2023," and "Statistics," with the active tab indicated by a shifting colored underline as the selection moves between tabs.

The Stars So Far!

Here's the current distribution of 2025 stars so far:

A statistical summary table for the year 2025, categorizing 685 book titles by star ratings, reviewing journals, recommended grades, and formats. The table lists counts for each category, including star ratings from 1 to 6 stars, reviews from journals such as Booklist and Kirkus, various grade levels from Birth to Grades 10+, and book formats including picture books, graphic novels, novels, and poetry collections.

Jennifer's Picks + Takeaways

As I've been preparing next semester's reading list for the Young Adult Literature Course I teach for Rutgers, I've leaned heavily on the starred review spreadsheet to help me narrow down selections. (Once the course has been published for students, I'll share this semester's reading list with the world!) That said, this focus on books written for readers between the ages or 12-18 has put a number of new/upcoming titles on my radar. Here are a few that I'm excited about!


A vertical collage featuring four book covers:

"Shampoo Unicorn" by Sawyer Lovett, featuring colorful watercolor-style hair flowing from the profile of a person's head, and a microphone.

"Ours to Tell: Reclaiming Indigenous Stories" by Eldon Yellowhorn and Kathy Lowinger, depicting photographs of Indigenous people surrounded by traditional patterns and symbols.

"A Bird in the Air Means We Can Still Breathe" by Mahogany L. Browne, showcasing bold, white typography against a backdrop of urban apartment buildings.

"Hunger's Bite" by Chloe Robin, illustrating a dramatic silhouette-style illustration of characters confronting a large shadowy creature with claws.

Title: Shampoo Unicorn

Author/Illustrator: Sawyer Lovett

Why I'm excited: When Erin Entrada Kelly calls a book the "most powerful debut of the year," I listen! That said, I'm particularly excited by the fact that this book is set in rural West Virginia and utilizes a podcast to tell the story. (I can't wait to listen to the audio book!) This starred review from PW captures more about why I quickly ordered this one!


"Acceptance and forgiveness are at the core of this timely novel, which gives voice to queer youth and amplifies the importance of connection and community."


Title: Ours to Tell: Reclaiming Indigenous Stories

Author/Illustrator: Eldon Yellowhorn & Kathy Lowinger

Why I'm excited: I create an inclusivity matrix for my YA Lit course to ensure that my own reading preferences/blind spots don't overly influence the reading list I create for students. Over the years I've come to recognize non-fiction as a category that I sometimes overlook. With that in mind, I am always excited to discover new non-fiction titles to review for the course - especially those that amplify marginalized voices. This starred review from SLJ convinced me to bump this title to the top of my TBR pile!


"This luminous work is more than a collective biography. It’s a reclamation of Indigenous stories, often manipulated, destroyed, and untold."


Title: A Bird In The Air Means We Can Still Breathe

Author/Illustrator: Mahogany L Browne

Why I'm excited: Honestly, it doesn't take much to convince me to read a new book by Mahogany L Browne. I've been a fan since Chlorine Sky hit shelves in 2021. This starred review from PW just sealed the deal!


"Poet Browne (Vinyl Moon) delivers a mournful remembrance of those who died during the pandemic in this love letter to New York City and its resilient teen population as they adjust to a changed world."


Title: Hunger's Bite

Author/Illustrator: Taylor Robin

Why I'm excited: Again, this one wasn't a hard sell, y'all. I mean.... it's a graphic novel set aboard a haunted ship where exhausted and exploited crew members team up with a vampire to fight the oppressive and predatory practices of the ship's new owner. Where do I sign up?? This review from PW made me all the more excited for this book!


"What starts as a charmingly funny interpretation of diverging adolescence evolves into a feverish nightmare that uses abstract paneling and character designs to examine capitalism and greed, resulting in a jumps-off-the-page thrill ride."


What Did I Miss?

As you might imagine, this project takes a lot of time and it's easy to make mistakes. Martha and I appreciate your help as we do our best to make sure the final product is as accurate as possible. That said, to be clear, we are not taking notes on misspellings, etc., but If, after at least a month**, you notice that we have missed a starred review from one of the journals we curate, please use this form to let us know. 


** Why do we ask you to wait a month? Some reviews appear online before that journal's official issue has been released. Waiting the month helps me avoid duplicating reviews.



 
 
black banner.png

Let's Connect!

  • Bluesky
  • instagram logo
  • gmail square
libgirlupandawayw_edited_edited.png
bottom of page